Brazilian cargo and charter airline Total Linhas Aéreas may be facing a landmark decision: the purchase of four COMAC C919 aircraft, the first passenger aircraft developed in China and considered a direct competitor to the Airbus A320neo and Boeing 737 Max. This move could not only revolutionize the Brazilian aviation sector, but also underline the potential of Chinese aircraft manufacturers in the international market.
The talks between Total Linhas Aéreas and the Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (COMAC) about the possible purchase of the C919 are a sign of how the dynamics in the aviation market could be shifting. The Brazilian airline, which currently operates a fleet of eight older aircraft, including refitted Boeing 727 and 737 freighters, is forced to look for alternatives to the established Western manufacturers. Both Airbus and Boeing have exhausted their supply capacities for new aircraft into the next decade, leaving Total Linhas Aéreas with the problem of acquiring new and modern aircraft in a timely manner.
With an average age of 29,4 years, the Brazilian airline's current fleet is one of the oldest in the country. The Boeing 727 in particular, which has reached an impressive age of over 46 years, represents a burden on flight operations and maintenance costs. Against this background, the possible purchase of the C919 appears not only a pragmatic but also a strategic decision to modernize operations and remain competitive.
The rise of the COMAC C919
The C919 was developed by COMAC as an alternative to the proven models from Airbus and Boeing and made its maiden flight in 2017. Since then, COMAC has delivered a total of 15 aircraft, including seven to China Eastern Airlines. The model has attracted particular interest in the domestic Chinese market, where large orders from China Southern Airlines, Air China and China Eastern Airlines have formed the backbone of the C919's success to date. The order for 100 aircraft by China Southern Airlines in 2023 underlines the confidence in the potential of this new aircraft type.
However, COMAC has so far struggled to gain a foothold in international markets. The aircraft's technical maturity, lack of global customer service and dependence on foreign suppliers such as General Electric and Honeywell have prevented many Western airlines from seriously considering purchasing the C919. With its potential order, Total Linhas Aéreas could become one of the first Western airlines to go down this route.
Brazil as a new market for COMAC?
If the purchase of four C919 aircraft by Total Linhas Aéreas goes ahead, it would not only be a breakthrough for COMAC in the South American market, but also an important test case for the Chinese aviation industry. Brazil is one of the largest aviation markets in Latin America, and the decision of a Brazilian airline could have a signaling effect for other airlines in the region. Especially in a market where Brazilian aircraft manufacturer Embraer has traditionally had a strong presence, the introduction of the C919 could change the competitive dynamic.
At the same time, Total Linhas Aéreas stresses that there are no satisfactory alternatives in the country. Embraer, known for its regional jets, does not offer an aircraft the size of the C919, which makes the Brazilian airline's search for a suitable model even more difficult.
Despite the interest in the C919, questions remain, particularly regarding the certification and operation of this aircraft outside of China. The C919 has not yet received certification from the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) or the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), which could complicate its use in international airlines. However, if COMAC makes progress in certifying its aircraft in other regions in the coming years, this could pave the way for more international orders.
For Total Linhas Aéreas, the question is also how well the C919 can be integrated into the existing fleet infrastructure. Maintenance, spare parts supply and staff training will be key factors for the success of this potential deal. However, a long-term partnership with COMAC could also mean that Total Linhas Aéreas gains access to the latest technology and assumes a pioneering role in South American aviation.
The possible order of the C919 by Total Linhas Aéreas is not only a business decision, but a potential turning point in global aviation. If the Brazilian airline does indeed choose the Chinese manufacturer, this could not only modernize Total's fleet, but also give COMAC important access to the international market. In an increasingly competitive market for aircraft, this could be the beginning of a new era in which Chinese manufacturers play a greater role.
and 