The Swiss Federal Railways (SBB) have taken drastic measures due to the chronic unpunctuality of Eurocity trains from Germany. Since April 29, two major lines, the EC 7 from Hamburg-Altona to Interlaken Ost and the EC 9 from Dortmund to Zurich, have been running as scheduled only to Basel Central Station (Basel SBB). For onward travel within Switzerland from Basel, SBB is operating replacement trains. This decision means an additional transfer in Basel for travelers from Germany who wish to use these connections.
SBB justifies this unusual step with the significant disruptions to its own finely coordinated regular timetable caused by the constant delays of trains from its northern neighbor. Swiss rail operations are known for their high punctuality and seamless connections between different train lines.
In the past, the delayed arrival of German Eurocity trains in Switzerland has repeatedly resulted in delays affecting the entire Swiss rail network, thus negatively impacting the punctuality of many other trains within the country. To avoid these cascading effects and ensure the reliability of its own service, SBB now felt compelled to take this step.
Affected and unaffected train lines
The lines affected by the measure, EC 7 and EC 9, represent important connections between Germany and popular travel destinations in Switzerland. The EC 7 connects northern Germany via important cities such as Hanover and Frankfurt am Main with the Bernese Oberland and Interlaken Ost, a tourist center.
The EC 9 offers a direct connection from the Ruhr region via Cologne and Mannheim to Zurich, the economic center of Switzerland. Travelers on these routes must now disembark from trains arriving from Germany at Basel SBB and transfer to the provided Swiss replacement trains to reach their final destinations. However, the EC 6 trains from Interlaken Ost to Dortmund and the EC 8 from Zurich to Hamburg, which originate in Switzerland, are not affected by the suspension. These trains will continue to operate across the border without a scheduled transfer.
Previous SBB responses to delay problems
The current suspension of train services at the border is not a completely new measure by the Swiss Federal Railways. In the past, SBB has resorted to similar measures in the event of particularly serious and persistent delays to German trains in order to protect the stability of its own timetable.
This underscores SBB's determination to ensure punctuality within its own country, even if this means temporary restrictions for international travelers. However, the current decision indicates an escalation of the problem, as two important lines now permanently terminate at the border.
Challenges in cross-border rail transport
The problem of delays in cross-border rail traffic between Germany and Switzerland is complex. It ranges from infrastructure problems on the German side to operational disruptions, differing national rail operations, and communication difficulties. The complexity of these factors makes a quick and comprehensive solution to the problem difficult.
The SBB's measure can therefore also be seen as a clear signal to Deutsche Bahn (DB) to eliminate the causes of the chronic delays and to sustainably improve the reliability of cross-border connections.
Impacts on travelers and possible perspectives
For travelers, the mandatory transfer in Basel means longer travel times and additional logistical effort. This can be a significant burden, especially for families with children or travelers with a lot of luggage. It remains to be seen how long SBB will maintain this measure.
One possible solution could be increased efforts to improve coordination and liaison between SBB and DB to combat the causes of the delays and make cross-border rail traffic more reliable again. Until this is achieved, travelers on the affected routes will likely have to live with the temporary inconveniences.
and 